- Though widely considered an aspect of human resources, performance management is something business owners should be mindful of as well.
- Establishing a measurable set of objectives for each employee is just one part of performance management.
- Performance management can bolster your employee retention figures, since reasonable expectations and understandable goals can motivate improvement.
When it comes to running a business of any size, information is key. From sales numbers and social media engagement to marketing lead conversion rates and operating costs, knowing how your company is faring compared to its overarching goals is paramount.
While it's always a good idea to keep an eye on your company at the macro level, you should apply that same attention to detail to individual employees. With a carefully considered performance management process, managers and employees can refocus their efforts and set expectations that line up with the company's goals.
Why performance management should be a priority
Regardless of how big or small your company may be, performance management is an important thing to consider. In fact, business owners "should be thinking about [performance management] from day one," according to Christine Tao, co-founder of Sounding Board.
"Performance management is really about understanding and motivating employees to perform effectively to support the broader goals of the organization," she said. "It's also about aligning the individual goals of employees to the broader goals of the organization – because if you can do so, you can help the company achieve peak performance in congruence with employees achieving individual peak performance."
Tao says performance management can help companies of all sizes "really take off and see success that is driven from its teams." If done correctly, performance management begins with an aligned set of measurable objectives for each employee and engenders a culture of learning and development for higher workplace performance. Armed with the knowledge of what's expected of them, each staff member should be motivated to improve their skills, competencies, development and delivery of results. [Read related article: How to Choose the Right Performance Management Software]
Consistent engagement vs. annual reviews
In most companies, the only evaluation employees receive from their supervisor or the human resource department is an annual performance review. In those conversations, employees are generally asked how they felt the past year went and what they can do to improve for the following year before receiving feedback. This boilerplate is potentially useful but predictable.
According to a January 2019 article in the Harvard Business Review, the general format and open-ended nature of performance evaluations is used because they must apply to everyone in an organization. That becomes a problem when "managers are expected to remember or figure out on their own what the specific expectations were for that particular employee," the article reads.
"The trouble is, when the context and criteria for making evaluations are ambiguous, bias is more prevalent. As many studies have shown, without structure, people are more likely to rely on gender, race, and other stereotypes when making decisions – instead of thoughtfully constructing assessments using agreed-upon processes and criteria that are consistently applied across all employees."
While that kind of appraisal helps illuminate the existing strengths and weaknesses of an individual staff member, a performance management process focuses on ongoing communication and accountability.
Experts believe that companies with an ongoing performance management process get better results than those that just have check-ins with management or human resources each year, since they can more easily root out what's not working and double down on what is.
With periodic meetings with management, employees benefit from a continual push to progress, rather than a sudden rush to meet objectives once their review rolls around. Removing that scramble can yield drastically more positive outcomes for employees, managers and organizations.
Once implemented, an effective performance management plan has these benefits for employees, managers and organizations:
- Improved communication: With regular check-ins from managers, employees are encouraged to communicate more freely about the company's objectives and their performance goals.
- Well-defined rules: With a better understanding of how they will be evaluated moving forward, employees and their managers can gauge how they're doing without waiting for the next review.
- Reduced stress: Everyone wants to be a good employee. Without feeling like they must try to impress a higher-up all the time, employees can focus on the task at hand. Meanwhile, managers are less likely to worry about offending underperforming employees.
Making sure your company's goals align with employee tasks
A major tenet of a good performance management plan is consistent focus on strategic goals and progress. Without that, employees are generally in the dark as to whether they made any solid improvements that contribute to the company.
Since employees need a clear understanding of what's expected of them and how their goals fit into the company's overarching success, it's important to set company goals to define what success even looks like. To that end, Gary Cokins, an expert with decades of experience in enterprise and corporate performance management, said it's up to the people at the top to establish what the company wants to achieve.
"If managers and employees don't understand the executive's strategy, how do we expect them to understand what they do each day, each week and in each decision?" he said. "Without that understanding, it's hard to make sure everything aligns with the [performance management plan]. It's the executive's job to ask, 'Where do we want to go?', but it's the managers' and employees' job to find out 'what we will do to get there.'" [Read related article: 6 Tips for Writing an Effective Performance Review]
Performance expectations should go beyond the job description to cover a range of expected outcomes. Here are some examples:
- What goods and services should the job produce?
- What effect should the work have on the company?
- How should employees act with clients, colleagues and supervisors?
- What organizational values should the employee demonstrate?
- What processes or methods should the employee use?
Some performance management steps to take
Establishing a strong performance management plan takes a lot of effort. Thinking about your company's needs and ensuring that your managers and other employees understand those goals through consistent communication is a lot to start with, but it can really be a boon to overall productivity and enthusiasm. [Check out BambooHR, our top pick for the best employee monitoring system for performance management.]
To kickstart the process, here are a few ways you can make sure you and your employees get the most out of performance management efforts.
1. Create measurable performance-based objectives and expectations.
Employees should understand and give input on how each objective's success is to be measured. Expectations generally fall into two categories:
- Results: These are the goods and services an employee produces, often measured by objectives or standards.
- Actions and behaviors: These are the methods used to make a product or perform a service, and the behaviors and values demonstrated during the process. They can be measured through performance dimensions.
2. Define professional development plans.
Supervisors and employees should work together to create development plans. The plan can focus on skills aimed at mastering the job or on professional development skills beyond the scope of the employee's job description. Employees should have a say in what new things they learn and how they can use those skills to the company's benefit.
3. Meet regularly to discuss overall progress and identify potential roadblocks.
Rather than waiting until an annual review, managers and employees should be actively engaged throughout the year to determine overall goal progress.
Additional reporting by Nicole Fallon, Ryan Goodrich and Jennifer Post.